The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period opened yesterday, and many seniors may find that their coverage options look very different than a year ago.
After several years of financial pressure, Medicare Advantage plans are reducing benefits, narrowing provider networks, exiting counties and, in some cases, leaving markets altogether. More than 3 million beneficiaries are enrolled in plans that have either been terminated or withdrawn from their county for 2027, meaning they will need to actively select new coverage.
As seniors evaluate their options, the 2027 Medicare Advantage Star Ratings—released by CMS last week—provide another important data point. The ratings help consumers compare plan quality and are tied to measures such as member experience, preventive care and chronic disease management.
This year, fewer plans achieved top ratings after CMS raised performance thresholds and modified its methodology. For example, the share of Medicare Advantage plans with prescription drug coverage earning four stars or higher fell from 44% to 37%, while the number of 5-star contracts declined from 22 to 15.
The results also highlight how much plan quality can vary across the Medicare Advantage landscape. While some insurers, including Humana and Devoted Health, improved their performance, others, such as UnitedHealthcare and Aetna, saw declines in the share of members enrolled in highly rated plans.
At a time when Medicare Advantage continues to face scrutiny over costs and payment policies, the program’s popularity remains difficult to ignore. More than half of eligible Medicare beneficiaries now choose Medicare Advantage coverage, demonstrating the program’s enduring appeal even as plans, regulators and beneficiaries navigate another year of change.
– Megan Hickey, Managing Director