This week, two of the Trump administration’s nominations for prominent HHS leadership positions faced an often-contentious nomination hearing before the Senate HELP Committee.
Outgoing Committee Chair Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La, did not mince words during his questioning of Dr. Erica Schwartz, the nominee for CDC Director: “We need a CDC director that will actually stand up to crazy, stupid things being said that undermine faith in immunization.”
Schwartz, who the administration has reportedly deemed a “non-controversial pick,” has built a career of civil service across her time in the Coast Guard, U.S. Public Health Service, and as Deputy Surgeon General under the prior Trump presidency. During her remarks, she committed to “never betray the science” and “always have the public’s health in mind.”
But many Senators didn’t seem convinced. Schwartz was non-committal when asked whether she would report attempts to implement unscientific or harmful policies, saying instead that she did not believe the president or HHS secretary would ever ask her to do so. Committee members were quick to remind Schwartz of former CDC Director Susan Monarez’s prior accounts of political interference.
Another nominee, aspiring Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response Sean Kaufman also drew the ire of the committee, particularly around his past comments regarding hepatitis B, COVID-19 immunization and mRNA vaccine research. During a heated exchange, Sen. Cassidy confronted Kaufman about his previous social media post linking hepatitis B vaccination and autism, asking, “Why would you repeat these lies?” while slamming his fist down.
The jury is still out on whether Schwartz and Kaufman did enough to win the votes of skeptical Senators. The committee is scheduled to meet next week to vote on advancing the noms. If even one Republican Senator votes no, their nominations will fail to move forward and the persistent vacancies across HHS leadership will remain.
– Rachel Bridges, Senior Director